WWW.THESES.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Theses, dissertations, documentation
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 12 | 13 || 15 | 16 |

«A thesis submitted to the faculty of San Francisco State University In partial fulfillment of The requirements for The degree Master of Arts In ...»

-- [ Page 14 ] --

Planning and implementing the flood control project generated a large number of linkages between elements, often creating additional problems. (Note: The number of linkages as detailed in Palm’s framework (Figures 2-4) increased noticeably from 1960 to the present day.) Each linkage increased the complexity of the project not only by involving a new element but also the policies and procedures of that element. The flood control project was at risk of stalling at several points due to the difficulties created by the many policies and regulations surrounding flood control, including the environmental impacts of a project. Ensuring that city staff understands these policies and regulations and the constraints they impose on hazard response before developing proposed solutions could speed up the cumbersome planning process. Another issue that plagued the flood control project was lack of or insufficient communication between elements.

This communication break in the linkage between elements sometimes put the entire

Kelsey McDonald - Thesis 135

project at risk, as when a failure to communicate with creekside residents early in the process threatened the entire project later when they learned about the floodwall and opposed it. Involving the majority of residents who will be impacted by a project in the earliest stages of the project and updating them directly (e.g. by mail) on a regular basis should improve the relationship between city staff and the residents and may also reduce the delays in the planning process.

Meso-level elements are perhaps the most complicated level of elements to evaluate, and not just due to their many links to other elements. Holmes’ role in the implementation of the flood control plan also points to the complexity of meso-level elements where an individual is acting in a meso-level role. Individuals acting in a mesolevel role are usually required to interpret their role and/or the policies of their organization and in doing this their individual values, experiences, and goals can influence how they carry out their role. When Scott Holmes acts on behalf of the city, his actions may not always represent his meso-level role. By deciding not to consult all parties after deciding with the Corps to remove the pipe, Holmes may have disregarded requirements of his role, but at the same time may have acted in the best interest of the city and residents by keeping the project moving forward. In addition, Holmes was willing to consider methods outside of the standard flood control methods used by public works departments for decades, and was able to provide an amenable solution to the flood problem.

–  –  –

example of the important influence an individual’s experiences and goals can have on the meso-level element they represent. The role of the committee was not only to help the city develop a flood control project but presumably also to represent the residents.

Although the committee generally supported many of the concerns expressed by different residents including protecting the environment, as this project demonstrates relying on a citizens committee to speak for the all residents can create tensions between city staff and the residents whose concerns have not been addressed.

Committee members acted based on their experiences and values, and were unlikely to have represented the views of all residents. When city staff and the committee communicated directly with the residents, they were able to address residents’ concerns and residents were less confrontational about the project.

Although when describing her integrative framework, Risa Palm acknowledges the significant influence an individual’s values and experiences can have on the mesolevel element they represent, she does not make this linkage explicit in her actual framework. The influence of individuals acting in meso-level roles, most significantly Scott Holmes, on the hazard response culminating in the San Pedro Creek Flood Control Project suggests that this connection should be incorporated into Palm’s framework. A revised framework could include a new “Micro in Meso” sub-level straddling the micro and meso levels (Figure 5), to represent the importance of these micro-level individuals acting in meso-level roles.

Kelsey McDonald - Thesis 137

FIGURE 5. Revised Integrative Framework with New Sub-Level. Modified from Palm 1990.

–  –  –

additional insight into why the third project has succeeded (at least in part to date).

After the 1962 flood the citizens Drainage Committee proposed major drainage improvements requiring $2 million in bonds to implement. Given that the flood seemed like a once in a lifetime event to some and that the entire community would be asked to fund the project through the bonds, the project likely had little public support and was eventually dropped. After the 1972 flood another citizens committee researched potential solutions to the problem. The repeated experience with flooding creating broader support for addressing the problem; however, an increased desire to protect the environment was not accommodated in the largely traditional structural flood control methods proposed and the project was dropped. Why did the third attempt at a flood control project ultimately succeed where the others had failed? In 1982 after the third and worst major flood in Linda Mar, many residents had several experiences with flooding and a more accurate perception of the flood hazard. Some of those residents became part of the third citizens’ flood control committee and were determined to take action and see the project through to completion. The committee strengthened their linkage with micro-level residents by working with residents who opposed the project to incorporate their concerns and gain their approval. Some of these micro-level residents even joined the meso-level flood control committee.





Likewise, Scott Holmes stepped into the meso-level role for the city at a point when the project was stalled due to opposition to the proposed floodwall. By developing a

Kelsey McDonald - Thesis 139

solution that addressed the concerns of most micro-level residents while also meeting the requirements of the involved meso-level elements, Holmes allowed planning to continue. Holmes’ proposed flood control plan incorporating restoration also allowed the city to obtain funding from organizations interested in environmental restoration. In order to implement the project, Holmes also broke it into phases so that it could be funded in increments instead of all at once.

If this study had evaluated the flood hazard response from either the human ecology or the political economic perspectives, instead of using Palm’s integrative framework, many influences would have been overlooked. A focus on human ecology would likely have missed the impacts of the environmental movement, federal and state regulations, and the availability of funding on the project. Likewise, if this study had concentrated on the structures and constraints of the political economic perspective, the influence of individuals opposing the project and other individuals supporting or pushing the project might not have emerged. In addition, this study finds the meso-level elements often neglected in the human ecology and political economic perspectives can have a significant influence on hazard response. For example, the post-1982 flood control committee helped keep the project moving forward for several decades, even getting help from state and federal politicians when the Corps delayed the project.

Scott Holmes, representative from the city, joined in the committee’s efforts in 1989 by proposing a new alternative that met the requirements of the different interests involved in the flood control project.

–  –  –

hazard response to flooding along San Pedro Creek. Factors that might lend additional insight into the hazard response include the impact of the real estate market on decisions at the meso- and micro-levels and the impact of other hazards in the area, such as landslides and earthquakes. More research into the individuals and how they get their news and information would also help the meso-level better communicate with the residents (micro-level) in the future.

As the San Pedro Creek Flood Control Project demonstrates, understanding a hazard response requires understanding influences coming from all levels, macro, meso, and micro, their environment, and the linkages between and among them. This complex interaction is highlighted well when placed into an integrative framework developed by Risa Palm; however, Palm’s framework should be expanded to include a new “Micro in Meso” sub-level to elevate the significance of micro-level elements acting in meso-level roles.

–  –  –

Anderson, Patricia. 1995. Letter to Mr. Lyndon Lee, L.C. Lee Associates, Inc., March 9.

In L.C. Lee & Associates, Inc., Draft Report to the City of Pacifica on the 75% Design for Restoring Lower San Pedro Creek and Adjacent Wetlands, 1995: Department of Fish and Game.

Association of State Floodplain Managers. 2000. National Flood Programs in Review - 2000 [cited November 2 2001]. Available from www.floods.org/PDF%20files/2000fpm.pdf.

Azevedo, Paul. 1989. The Reactor: Protecting Our Creek. Pacifica Tribune, February 15, 13A.

Azevedo, Paul, and Lydia Azevedo. 2002. Personal Communication, April 3. Pacifica, California.

Barnard, Sue. 1982a. Eighty Flee to Terra Nova Shelter. Pacifica Tribune, January 6, 2.

———. 1982b. Linda Mar Floods: The Third Time. Pacifica Tribune, January 6, 10.

Barrows, Harlan H. 1923. Geography as Human Ecology. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 13 (1):1-14.

Before the Sanchez Adobe. (Research by Alan Brown). 1957. La Peninsula 9 (2):3-6.

Bolton, Herbert Eugene, ed. 1926. Historical Memoirs of New California by Fray Francisco Palou, O.F.M. Vol. V3. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Brown, Alan. 1961. From Cattle to Cabbages. La Peninsula 11 (1).

Brown, Alan K. 1973-74. Indians of San Mateo County. La Peninsula 17 (4).

Browne, Joe. 1994. Letter to Dr. Lyndon C. Lee, President, L.C. Lee & Associates, Inc., December 8. In L.C. Lee & Associates, Inc., Draft Report to the City of Pacifica on the 75% Design for Restoring Lower San Pedro Creek and Adjacent Wetlands, 1995.

California Dept. of Transportation.

Kelsey McDonald - Thesis 142

Burcham, L. T. 1957. California Range Land: An Historico-Ecological Study of the Range Resource of California. Sacramento: Division of Forestry, Dept. of Natural Resources, State of California.

Burton, I. 1962. Types of Agricultural Occupance of Flood Plains in the United States.

Research Paper No. 75. Chicago: University of Chicago, Department of Geography.

Burton, I, R. W. Kates, and G. F. White. 1978. The Environment as Hazard. New York:

Oxford University Press.

Cardoza, Leonard E. 1992. Letter to Honorable Tom Lantos. San Francisco, California, November 16.

Chorley, R. J. 1973. Geography as Human Ecology. In Directions in Geography, edited by R. J. Chorley. London: Methuen and Company.

City of Pacifica. 1990. Draft Council Agenda Summary Report, City of Pacifica, Community Development and Services Department, Wastewater Division, November 13. Pacifica, California.

———. 2000. Council Agenda Summary Report, Public Works Department, January 24, Agenda Item. Pacifica, California.

———. 2001. City of Pacifica: 1980 General Plan. Updated March 2001. Pacifica, California.

———. (no date). City of Pacifica (Map). Dept. of Public Works, Pacifica, California.

City of Pacifica (City) and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE). 2000. San Pedro Creek Flood Control and Ecosystem Restoration Project, Pacifica, CA, August.

Collins, Laurel, Paul Amato, and Donna Morton. 2001. San Pedro Creek Geomorphic Analysis.

Cross, J. A. 1991. Geographical Reviews: Natural Hazards: An Integrative Framework for Research and Planning. By Risa I. Palm. Geographical Review 81 (1):126-127.

Curtis, Janice. 1990a. Meeting Tonight: New Solution Suggested To Stop Creek Flooding. Pacifica Tribune, August 29, 1, 14A.

———. 1990b. Wetlands Marsh Plan Made to Order. Pacifica Tribune, September 5, 1, 16A.

Kelsey McDonald - Thesis 143

———. 1990c. Marsh Alternative Takes Step Forward. Pacifica Tribune, October [date unknown].

———. 1990d. Flood Plan Presented to Army Engineers. Pacifica Tribune, November 14, 1, 16A.

———. 1991a. Money biggest problem for flood control plan. Pacifica Tribune, March 13, 1, 16A.

———. 1991b. Flood control plan's big test is April 22. Pacifica Tribune, April 17, 1, 16A.

———. 1992. Progress stalls on flood control project. Pacifica Tribune, February 5.

Cutter, Susan L. 1991. Book Review: Natural Hazards: An Integrative Framework for Research and Planning. By Risa I. Palm. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 81 (4):701-712.

———, ed. 1994. Environmental Risks and Hazards. Edited by S. L. Cutter. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice Hall.

Davis, Jerry. 2004. San Pedro Creek Watershed (Map): San Francisco State University.

———. 2002. San Pedro Creek Watershed (Map): San Francisco State University.

Delaplaine, Mark. 1995. Letter from Mark Delaplaine, Federal Consistency Supervisor, California Coastal Commission, to Bill DeJager, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, San Francisco District. September 6. Appendix J. In San Pedro Creek Section 205 Flood Control Study. Final Detailed Project Report. Volume I: Main Report and Environmental Impact Statement/Report, edited by U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and City of Pacifica (City).

Dietz, Stephen A. 1979. Report of Archaeological Investigations at Sanchez Adobe Park Historic District: Archaeological Consulting and Research Services, Inc. with contributions by M. Bredemeyer, R. Milliken, D. Simons, and L. White.

Drake, Robert J. 1951. Samplings in History at the Sanchez Adobe, San Mateo County, California: Department of Anthropology, University of New Mexico.

Farrel, David. 1995. Letter from David Farrel, Chief, Office of Federal Activities, U.S.



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 12 | 13 || 15 | 16 |


Similar works:

«barceló atom barceló atom BARCELO ATOM ESPAÑA graphispag.com Postimpresión, transformación y acabados. SISTEMA DE CORTE AUTOMATICO POR CUCHILLA CON GRUPO CABEZAS DE DOBLE EJE VERTICAL INDEPENDIENTE Y Mesa de corte por cuchilla Atom Mesa de corte por cuchilla, Modelo FlashCut 888 de Barcelo Atom España. Vea detalles y solicite presupuesto. Atom Dominicana facebook.com Atom Dominicana, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic. 944 likes · 2 talking about this · 1 was here. Disfruta tus...»

«A Kick in the Teeth. The equestrian monument to ‘Field Marshal Earl Haig, Commander-in-Chief of the British Armies in France 1915-1918’ by Alfred Hardiman. Nicholas Watkins Set on a scrolled, sloping bronze base, placed on a high stone pedestal in the centre of Whitehall, with hind legs drawn back like pistons, off fore slammed down at the halt and near fore pounding forward at the trot, the mighty stylised, ‘classical’ horse carries a more naturalistic Field Marshal Earl Haig...»

«136 Bible Contradictions..Answered By Brad McCoy, ThM © Copyright 1985 Reprinted with author’s permission. May be distributed freely but not sold. Introduction This booklet is a response to the pamphlet “136 Bible Contradictions” printed by Crusade publications of Redmond, Washington. This writer begins with two presuppositions (1) God exists (2) God reveals. God has revealed Himself and His truth through His creation (general revelation) and through His writing, in the written Word of...»

«Welcome to Grace Lutheran Church We are glad that you have joined us for this afternoon’s Bach Cantata Vespers. For those who have trouble hearing, sound enhancement units are available in the back of the church and may be obtained from an usher. Please silence all cell phones and pagers. Recording or photography of any kind during the service is strictly forbidden. This afternoon’s Bach Cantata Vespers is generously underwritten by the Sukup Family Foundation. The Seventeenth Sunday after...»

«The Floating Arabic Dictionary: An Automatic Method for Updating a Lexical Database through the Detection and Lemmatization of Unknown Words Mohammed Attia1,3 Younes Samih2 Khaled Shaalan1 Josef van Genabith3 (1) The British University in Dubai, UAE (2) Heinrich-Heine-Universität, Germany (3) School of Computing, Dublin City University, Ireland {mattia,josef}@computing.dcu.ie, samih@phil.uni-duesseldorf.de, khaled.shaalan@buid.ac.ae ABSTRACT Unknown words, or out of vocabulary words (OOV),...»

«Actualización de Firmware para EOS 7D, Versión 1.0.9 Cambios en el firmware La Versión 1.0.9 del firmware incorpora lo siguiente: 1. Mejora la precisión del enfoque automático (AF) durante la toma en el modo “Live View” (Visión en Directo).2. Corrige un fenómeno por el cual, en raras ocasiones, es posible que las imágenes de película tomadas por la cámara muestren colores irregulares.3. Corrige un fenómeno por el cual, en ciertos momentos, el obturador no se libera cuando se usa...»

«Dr. Ulrich Schenck Reviewing local Policies of the past decades and Analyzing current Flows of EU migrants This publication has been produced with financial support from the European Union’s Fundamental Rights and Citizenship Programme. The information and views set out in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official opinion of the Commission. The Commission does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this publication. Neither the...»

«The Recent Attempt To Defeat The Constitutional Provisions In Favor Of Religious Freedom Bbq Market understand they wait influencing your wash on The Recent Attempt to Defeat the Constitutional Provisions in Favor of Religious Freedom the process of your social with who has great. Over you've an much you would bring up onto some quiet commission of assist for their insurers. Your sales can so more stick to also web this growth for a culture. You are positively frozen to matter the rates than to...»

«Claudia García Saludar al cerro y consulta popular. Cosmovisión y minería en La misión del Sarima’ y Bajo el mismo cielo University of Nebraska at Omaha, EE.UU. csgarcia@unomaha.edu La firma de los Acuerdos de Paz, en diciembre de 1996, constituyó el fin oficial de más de tres décadas de guerra interna en Guatemala. El conflicto armado y la violencia política guatemalteca no fueron fenómenos aislados sino instancias de un proceso común a diversas regiones latinoamericanas, desde el...»

«PRACTICE CS Sample Reports version 2012.x.x TL 25842 (10/24/12) Copyright Information Text copyright 2004 – 2012 by Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Video display images copyright 2004 – 2012 by Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. Thomson Reuters hereby grants licensees of CS Professional Suite software the right to reprint this document solely for their internal use. Trademark Information The trademarks used herein are trademarks and registered trademarks used under license. All...»

«WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL Once we have computed the costs of the individual components of the firm’s financing, we would assign weight to each financing source according to some standard and then calculate a weight average cost of capital (WACC) Financial analysts frequently focus on a firm’s total capitalization, which is the sum of its longterm debt of equity (capital structure) or mix of long-term sources of funds used by the firm. It is also referred to as firm’s...»

«THE EFFECTS OF SUPERVISORS’ VERBAL AGGRESSIVENESS AND MENTORING ON THEIR SUBORDINATES Paul E. Madlock Texas A&M International University Carrie Kennedy-Lightsey West Virginia University This study examined the association between supervisors’ mentoring and verbal aggression and their subordinates’ perceived communication satisfaction, job satisfaction, and organizational commitment. The findings of the 200 full-time working adults who participated in the study supported prior research...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.theses.xlibx.info - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.