FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Pages:     | 1 ||


-- [ Page 2 ] --

Goodrich Co. v. Hughes, 194 So. 842, 847 (Ala. 1940); Gregath v. Bates, 359 So. 2d 404, 409 (Ala. Civ. App. 1978). In Gregath, plaintiffs sued the owners of two hog parlors located near plaintiffs’ home. Id. at 406. Plaintiffs alleged that odors, flies, and contaminated water from the hog parlors were coming onto their property causing them to be sick and leaving their nervous systems shattered. Id. In considering plaintiffs’ request for damages related to their alleged

physical and mental suffering, the court stated:

–  –  –

Id. at 409 (emphasis added and internal citations omitted). The Court in Hughes reached the same conclusion. In that case, plaintiff sued for trespass and conversion of an automobile. 194 So. at 845. Plaintiff claimed damages for medical expenses associated with his physical and mental symptoms arising from the alleged wrong committed against his property. Id. The Court

held that such damages were not recoverable, stating:

–  –  –

Id. at 847 (internal citations omitted).

Essentially, the courts in Hughes and Gregath concluded that damages for nervous reactions (i.e., physical symptoms resulting solely from mental anguish) are only recoverable if, under Alabama law, damages could be recovered for the underlying mental anguish. See Hughes, 194 So. at 847; Gregath, 359 So. 2d at 409. Based on the allegations in the complaint, to the extent plaintiffs in this case are alleging any physical symptoms, those alleged symptoms appear to solely arise, if at all, from plaintiffs’ claimed mental anguish in connection with damage to their property. Thus, under Hughes and Gregath, plaintiffs cannot recover any damages for those alleged symptoms.

Yarber was in California and Whitfield was at his girlfriend’s home in Vestavia Hills, Alabama, when the crash occurred. (P. Yarber Answers to Interrogs., Resp. Interrog. No. 5; C.

Whitfield Answers to Interrogs., Resp. Interrog. No. 5.) Therefore, they could not have been physically injured in connection with the crash. Accordingly, any physical bodily injury they are alleging would necessarily be limited to physical symptoms solely caused by mental anguish relating to property damage. As discussed above, Yarber and Whitfield cannot recover any damages for that alleged, underlying mental anguish. Any physical symptoms they allegedly have as a result of their professed emotional reaction to the property damage would constitute nervous reactions under Hughes and Gregath for which damages are not recoverable. As discussed above, based on the allegations in the complaint and the absence of any evidence of physical injuries suffered by the Bensons in connection with the crash, the only physical symptoms it appears the Bensons could arguably have would also be the kind of nervous reactions discussed in Hughes and Gregath for which no damages are recoverable.

For the foregoing reasons, UPS is entitled to partial summary judgment with respect to any demand for damages based on physical symptoms allegedly suffered by plaintiffs.

WHEREFORE, UPS respectfully requests that the Court enter partial summary judgment in favor of UPS with respect to (a) plaintiffs’ claims for mental anguish and (b) any demand by plaintiffs for damages associated with mental anguish or alleged physical symptoms resulting solely from claimed mental anguish.

–  –  –



213 Greene Street Huntsville, Alabama 35801 Telephone Number: (256) 536-0095 Facsimile Number: (256) 536-4440 E-mail: court@fb-pc.com


I hereby certify that on the 22nd day of April, 2014, I electronically filed the foregoing with the Clerk of Court using the Alacourt/Alafile system which will send notification of such

filing to the following:

–  –  –

Pages:     | 1 ||

Similar works:

«HOLSTEIN FOUNDATION AYRSHIRE QUIZ BOWL 2016 PRACTICE QUESTIONS 1. While most consumers associate milk with high calcium content, they don't realize that whole milk is what percent fat-free? 97% (Dairy Herd Management) 2. What two feedstuffs might you add to a calf's ration in order to make the calf like the taste? Molasses and oats (HF Workbooks) 3. Fertility, as measured by daughter pregnancy rate, is lowest in which breed? Guernsey (Hoard's Dairyman) 4. When a cow is in a flotation tank,...»

«IDB WORKING PAPER SERIES No. IDB-WP-528 Shelter from the Storm: Upgrading Housing Infrastructure in Latin American Slums Sebastián Galiani, Paul Gertler, Ryan Cooper, Sebastián Martínez, Adam Ross, Raimundo Undurraga Inter-American Development Bank Office of Strategic Planning and Development Effectiveness Shelter from the Storm: Upgrading Housing Infrastructure in Latin American Slums Sebastián Galiani, Paul Gertler, Ryan Cooper, Sebastián Martínez, Adam Ross, Raimundo Undurraga...»

«! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Billings Pro User Guide (Last updated: August 25th, 2014) ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Quick Tip To search for a specific word, use the command+F keyboard shortcut to open the seach field Table of Contents ! Overview! 5! System Requirements! 5! Licensing Billings Pro! 6! Ecosystem! 6! Background Sync! 6! Installing Billings Pro ! 7! Billings Pro Setup Assistant! 7! The Billings Pro User Interface! 9! The Sidebar! 10! The Projects list! 12!...»

«A Supervisor’s Guide to FINDING AND SELECTING EXCELLENT VISTA LEADERS This Action Learning Team project was completed by: Brad Hunter, VISTA Leader—Maine Commission for Community Service Kathleen Burkhardt, VISTA Leader—American Red Cross of Greater Indianapolis Patrick Magee-Jenks, VISTA Leader—Colorado Youth Corps Association Jean Carroccio—Team Facilitator TABLE OF CONTENTS:  Introduction 3 How to Use this Guide  VISTA Leader Traits, Definitions and Benefits 4 What makes a...»

«IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS OF TENNESSEE AT KNOXVILLE Assigned on Briefs August 24, 2010 STATE OF TENNESSEE v. ANGELA MILHORN Direct Appeal from the Criminal Court for Sullivan County No. S56,755 Robert H. Montgomery, Jr., Judge No. E2010-00458-CCA-R3-CD Filed October 15, 2010 The defendant, Angela Milhorn, appeals the denial of her request for judicial diversion, arguing that the trial court abused its discretion by placing undue emphasis on the circumstances of her offense while ignoring...»

«Mureddu, N. (2013) ‘A Barrier to be Broken: Change and Continuity in the Transition between the Bronze and Iron Age Aegean’ Rosetta 13.5: 22-32. http://www.rosetta.bham.ac.uk/Colloquium2013/mureddu.pdf Rosetta 13.5. http://www.rosetta.bham.ac.uk/Colloquium2013/mureddu.pdf A Barrier to be Broken: Change and Continuity in the Transition between the Bronze and Iron Age Aegean Nicola Mureddu Over a century has now passed since the first discoveries of Bronze Age civilisations in the Aegean and...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.theses.xlibx.info - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.