FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 8 |

«IZA DP No. 3901 A Behavioral Account of the Labor Market: The Role of Fairness Concerns Ernst Fehr Lorenz Goette Christian Zehnder December 2008 ...»

-- [ Page 3 ] --

Survey evidence on the prevalence of different compensation forms indicates that there seem to be strong limits to the usage of explicit incentive contracts. Explicit performance pay is still the exception rather than the rule. The vast majority of workers is compensated with hourly wages or salaries and not governed by formal incentive contracts (MacLeod & Parent 1999).

The fact the many firms seem to be constrained to pay flat wages obviously does not mean that they are unable to provide incentives to their workers. Even if the worker's compensation does not explicitly depend on performance, the employer may use the threat of dismissal in case of poor performance or the promise of promotion for extraordinary performance to motivate the worker. In order for these implicit incentives to be effective, it is essential that the worker judges remaining with his current employer to be more attractive than his next best alternative. In other words: the prospect of keeping his job (or getting promoted) must provide the worker with a non-competitive rent. The literature on conditional contract renewals in repeated interactions between employers and workers shows that such implicit incentives can endogenously enforce the provision of non-minimal effort under incomplete employment contracts (MacLeod & Malcomson 1989; MacLeod & Malcomson 1993; MacLeod & Malcomson 1998; Shapiro & Stiglitz 1984). The basic mechanism in all these models is that the employer provides incentives to perform by conditioning the renewal (or the terms) of the employment contract on the worker's past performance.

3.2 The Role of Fairness Concerns under Incomplete Relational Contracting In the ultimatum game, concerns for fairness and reciprocity cause rejections of unfair offers and induce proposers to make fair offers. In the context of contractually incomplete employment relations such concerns are also likely to affect workers' effort choices. The reason is that the preference for fairness or reciprocity induces workers to choose a higher effort to raise the firm's payoff in response to wage increases (Akerlof 1982; Akerlof & Yellen 1990; Benjamin 2005). However, as we discussed in section 2, there is considerable individual heterogeneity in the preference for fairness and reciprocity, and a significant share of subjects often behaves in a completely selfish manner. As a consequence, the one-shot effects of fairness may not be strong enough to make the provision of non-competitive wage premia profitable.

The prevalence of repeated interactions in relational labor contracts, however, greatly amplifies the possibilities for fairness concerns to play a decisive role. This holds even if employers and employees know that they will only interact for a limited number of periods, i.e., even in cases of very limited time horizons. In a finitely repeated context, the presence of even a small fraction of fair-minded workers may also motivate purely selfish workers to exert effort in response to receiving a wage rent (Brown et al 2004; 2008; Kreps et al 1982).

The intuition is that selfish workers have an incentive to exert effort in order to maintain a good reputation and make the employer believe that they are (at least potentially) fair-minded.

Such a reputation is valuable for selfish workers because finite repetition implies that the employer only pays non-competitive rents to workers who have not yet been identified as selfish. The firm anticipates that a selfish worker will always shirk in the final period of the interaction, which unravels all incentives to pay a rent in any period if a worker is known to be selfish. Fair-minded workers, in contrast, exert effort whenever they are paid a fair wage rent. Thus, if the belief about an individual worker's fair-mindedness is high enough, the employer will be willing to pay a high wage even in the last period. Note that the employer's willingness to pay a rent to fair workers disciplines the selfish worker because if the worker shirks he will be identified as a selfish type which, in turn, implies that he will not be paid a rent in the future.

It is important to stress that the existence of reputation equilibria in which all workers – selfish and fair-minded – put forward high effort despite the absence of explicit incentives does not require a large share of fair-minded workers. It is perfectly possible for the fraction of fair-minded individuals to be so small that firms would optimally refrain from paying noncompetitive wage premia in one-shot interactions, while finding it profitable to pay such premia in the reputation equilibria of finitely repeated interactions.

It is sometimes argued that the assumption of the existence of fair-minded individuals in infinitely repeated games is not needed to prove the existence of equilibria with noncompetitive wage rents.6 Even if all people are selfish, non-competitive rents can be equilibrium phenomena, provided that interactions are infinitely repeated. While, this argument is true, it is not important for our purposes because the existence of fair-minded subjects is an empirical fact. Physicists also don’t argue that we can explain sunset and sundown by assuming that the sun orbits around the earth although this incorrect assumption can provide a superficially plausible explanation for these phenomena. In addition, as the next section shows, it is an empirical fact that selfish subjects mimic fair-minded behaviors in repeated interactions (see e.g. Fehr, Brown, and Zehnder 2009). Moreover, because there are The papers by Shapiro and Stiglizt (1984) and Malcomson and MacLeod (1989, 1998) demonstrate the existence of such equilibria.

fair subjects, the range of parameter values (e.g. discount factors) for which equilibria with non-competitive wage premia exist is greatly expanded. Finally, fairness concerns may play a role as an equilibrium selection device, as argued in MacLeod and Malcomson (1998)7 and judgments regarding the fairness of performance evaluations are important whenever performance cannot be objectively assessed (MacLeod 2003).

4 Motivating Workers: Evidence on the Role of Fairness and Reputation In this section, we discuss the empirical role of fairness preferences for the motivation problem in contractually incomplete employment relationships. The cleanest evidence comes from laboratory experiments which implement the essential strategic features of the interaction between employer and worker. In interpreting the lab studies, there is a natural concern that the effects of fairness identified in the lab may not carry over to the labor markets outside the laboratory (Levitt & List 2007). However, we can allay these doubts by illustrating that the laboratory results are consistent with the findings in field experiments which implement explicit wage manipulations in real-life work environments and other field evidence from instances when firms changed the conditions in employment relationships.

In the first part of the section, we review evidence on the impact of fairness in one-shot encounters between employers and workers. Since reputational considerations cannot play a role in these situations, this evidence reveals the extent to which fairness motives alone help to overcome incentive problems in employment relationships. While there is clear-cut evidence that a non-negligible number of individuals are fair-minded and respond to higher wages by exerting more effort, the evidence also shows that many people are quite selfish and fairness concerns alone may not be sufficient to overcome the motivation problem in Another argument that is sometimes put forward is that because many interactions in real life are repeated, people apply rules of thumb or habits of fair behavior in one-shot interactions. However, while it is true that many interactions are repeated, people in modern societies also face many one-time encounters. Moreover, for our account of the labor market the origin of fairness preferences is not important. Whether many of us behave fairly because our parents imputed these values into our brains, or whether genes favor fair behaviors, is not important for our purposes. We have to take such behaviors seriously regardless of their evolutionary or educational origins.

incomplete employment contracts. In fact, if fairness concerns are the only force that drives effort above non-minimal levels, there are in general large unexploited efficiency gains.

In the second part, we discuss how labor market outcomes change if employer and worker have the option of interacting repeatedly with each other. We show that reputational incentives in endogenously formed long-term relationships greatly magnify the impact of fairness on performance. In fact, the data indicate that the interaction between fairness and reputation effects can be sufficiently strong to sustain high levels of efficiency, even when the

impact of fairness preferences alone is very weak.

4.1 Fairness in Spot Interactions A well suited game for studying the impact of wage rents on effort is the so-called giftexchange game, which was introduced by Fehr et al (1993). The gift-exchange game is a twoplayer game that captures the basic strategic features of an incomplete employment contract.

The structure of the game is as follows: the employer offers a wage to the worker and requests a certain level of effort. While the wage payment is binding, the requested effort level is not enforceable. The worker can either accept or reject the employer's offer. In case of acceptance, the worker can choose his actual effort level. The worker can choose any effort level and is not restricted by the employer's request. If the worker rejects the offer, he receives an unemployment benefit. The employer's profit is equal to the returns generated by the worker's effort minus the wage payment. The worker's payoff, in turn, is calculated as the wage minus the cost of effort. The parameters are usually chosen in such a way that the efficient outcome is achieved when the worker chooses the maximal effort level.

Since providing effort is costly, the self-interest model predicts that the worker always provides the smallest possible effort. However, if fairness considerations matter and workers are willing to reciprocate a generous wage with higher effort, it may be profitable for employers to offer wages that exceed the worker's outside-option.

A typical example for a one-shot gift exchange experiment is the baseline treatment in Brown, Falk and Fehr (2004). Each employer can at most hire one worker in each period and each worker can have in maximum one job. The matching of workers and firms occurs in a simple labor market with an excess supply of workers. A match occurs when a worker accepts a firm's offer. Although the market runs for several periods, reputation formation cannot play a role, because employers cannot distinguish workers from each other when they make wage offers. The results confirm that higher wage offers by firms, on average, induce workers to provide more effort. However, while effort is significantly higher than the minimal effort predicted by self-interest, it is also far below the efficient level8. The reason for the limited impact of fairness on performance is found in the huge inter-individual differences across subjects. Although there are the fair-minded workers, there is also a substantial share of workers who make mostly selfish choices. The relationship between wages and effort is steep enough to render wage offers above the worker's outside option profitable, but the presence of selfish agents restrains many principals from offering wage rents which would be high enough to induce efficient effort levels from fair-minded workers.

The finding that the impact of fairness alone on market performance is positive but small is very robust and has also been confirmed in a number of other laboratory studies using students as participants (Charness 2004; Charness et al 2004; Falk & Gaechter 2002; Fehr et al 1993; Hannan et al 2002). All report evidence from one-shot gift-exchange experiments and find results very similar to those reported above: wages and effort are always positively correlated, but the realized effort level is far from efficient. Fehr et al (1998) and List (2006) replicate the gift-exchange findings in laboratory experiments with non-student subject pools (soldiers and sportscard enthusiasts, respectively) and find that the realized effort levels are similar to those reported in the previous literature.

In order to assess the external validity of the laboratory findings on the impact of fairness on performance in employment relationships, several recent studies report evidence from field Workers can choose effort levels between 1 and 10 where 10 is the efficient effort level. The realized average effort level is about 3.

experiments on gift-exchange. These studies aim to test the proposition that higher wages are perceived as fairer and consequently elicit higher effort in real-life work environments.

Pages:     | 1 | 2 || 4 | 5 |   ...   | 8 |

Similar works:

«Revista Visión Empresarial N° Escuela de Administración de Empresas y Marketing Ensayo: Análisis de los Canales de Distribución de la Industria Lechera Gloria y su incidencia en la competitividad en el mercado Anexo 7. Artículo Científico Análisis de los Canales de Distribución de la Industria Lechera Gloria y su incidencia en la competitividad en el mercado (Entregado 07/07/2015 – Revisado 06/08/2015) Escuela de Administración de Empresas y Marketing (EAEM) Universidad Politécnica...»

«Dear Prospective DNP Student: We are pleased that you are interested in applying for admission into the Doctor of Nursing Program (DNP) at Wilmington University. Applications for the DNP Program are accepted from individuals who have a master’s degree and are advanced practice nurses as NP, CNS, CRNA or CNM from an accredited institution. The program is available in a modified hybrid format (Fall admission) at the Wilson Graduate Center site in New Castle County or 100% online (Spring...»

«Current Movies Listing Spanish Movie Director: Kike Maíllo Toro (Nov16) Cast: Mario Casas, Luis Tosar, José Sacristán My Friend From The Park Director: Ana Katz Cast: Julieta Zylberberg, Ana Katz, Maricel (Nov16) Alvarez, Mirella Pascual Director: Miguel Ángel Lamata Our Lovers (Oct16) Cast: Eduardo Noriega, Michelle Jenner Director: Daniel Calparsoro To Steal From A Thief (Sep16) Cast: Luis Tosar, Rodrigo de la Serna, Raúl Arévalo, Jose Coronado Director: David Serrano We Need to Talk...»


«REMITTITUR SUGGESTED, MODIFY and AFFIRM; Opinion Filed December 16, 2015. S In The Court of Appeals Fifth District of Texas at Dallas No. 05-14-01137-CV BISHOP ABBEY HOMES, LTD. AND NATHAN HALSEY, Appellants V. BRYON AND PAIGE HALE, Appellees On Appeal from the 439th Judicial District Court Rockwall County, Texas Trial Court Cause No. 1-11-1207 MEMORANDUM OPINION Before Justices Lang-Miers, Brown, and Schenck Opinion by Justice Lang-Miers Appellees Bryon and Paige Hale sued appellants Bishop...»

«Book Reviews Sociology of Sport Journal, 2007, 24, 346-354 © 2007 Human Kinetics, Inc. Growing the Game: The Globalization of Major League Baseball By Alan Klein. Published in 2004 by Yale University Press, New Haven. (288 pp., $30.00 US). Reviewed by Michael L. Butterworth, School of Communication Studies, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, OH. In December, 2006, the Boston Red Sox signed Japanese pitcher Daisuke Matsuzaka to a 6-year, $52 million contract. This came only after...»

«2013-2014 Chain Reaction Contraption Contest Official Handbook www.chainreactioncontest.org Friday, December 13, 2013 Table of Contents Title Page Number I.  Background II.  This Year’s Challenge III.  Contest Outline IV.  Rules V.  Important Dates Appendix A: Forms Conceptual Design Form Photographic Progress Report 1 Form (Page 1 of 2) Photographic Progress Report 1 Form (Page 2 of 2) Photographic Progress Report 2 Form (Page 1 of 2) Photographic Progress Report 2 Form (Page 2 of 2)...»

«Country Advice Jordan Jordan – JOR40065 – Palestinians – Discrimination – Marriage – Honour Killings 5 April 2012 1. Please provide information on the treatment of people of Palestinian origin. No information was located that suggested Jordanian nationals of Palestinian origin have, as a specific group, been subject to serious mistreatment over recent years in terms of suffering physical harm or imprisonment. However, a number of reports were found that claim Palestinian Jordanians...»

«Extra-Statutory Concessions Concessions as at 6 April 2016 The Civil Partnership Act (CPA) received Royal Assent on 18/11/2004 and became effective from 5 December 2005. The Government’s commitment is that, for all tax purposes, same-sex couples who form a civil partnership will be treated the same as married couples. As part of this commitment to tax parity, from 5 December 2005 all Extra Statutory Concessions (ESCs) or Statements of Practice (SoPs) should be taken as extended to apply...»

«News Bulletin January 3, 2012 A Blueprint for Contingent Convertible Securities? It has probably not escaped the attention of the reader that European banks, and their ability to meet their continuing funding needs, have been some of the principal victims of the continuing uncertainty surrounding the future of the Eurozone, due to their exposures to Eurozone sovereign debt. As part of its general efforts to increase market confidence in European banks, the European Banking Authority (EBA)...»

«238 Trop Anim Prod 1977 2:3 PROTEIN REQUIREMENT AND NON PROTEIN NITROGEN UTILIZATION Larry D Satter and Robert R Roffler2 Department of Dairy Science University of Wisconsin Madison 53706 Factors governing nitrogen utilization by dairy cattle include the following: (a) Maintenance of ruminal ammonia nitrogen in excess of 5 mg/100 ml rumen fluid has no effect on microbial protein production; (b) Supplemental NPN is not utilized in typical dairy and feedlot beef rations containing, more than 12...»

«Another Europe Given the recent focus on the challenges to representative democracy, and the search for new institutions and procedures that can help to channel increasing participation, this book offers empirical insights on alternative conceptions of democracy and the actors that promote them. With a focus on the conceptions and practices of democracy within contemporary social movements in Europe, this volume contributes to the debate on the different dimensions of democracy, especially on...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.theses.xlibx.info - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.