FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Pages:     | 1 | 2 ||

«This book is about language and the city. Pennycook and Otsuji introduce the notion of ‘metrolingualism’, showing how language and the city are ...»

-- [ Page 3 ] --

7. T: Get that one and we’ll get you another one. [to the customer] Between lines 1 and 4, Muhibb and Talib continue to deal with the zucchini order, confirming the number of boxes and price and using English and Arabic resources in a mixture common to second generation immigrants working in such an environment. Here, however, Talib’s use of Arabic to acknowledge that the zucchini they are trying to sell have turned yellow (line 5) is picked up by the customer: He knows the meaning of isfar (lines 6). This seems to concur with Joseph’s view that they know a bit of each other’s languages, though in the case of Maltese and Arabic, this is not wholly surprising (isfar is also the Maltese for yellow). More generally, however, this shows how people draw on their own resources in achieving tasks at hand and how items such as yellow zucchini (the food rather than the linguistic form) play a mediating role in the metrolingual action. Metrolingual practices concern the whole package of linguistic resources, personal trajectories and repertoires, objects and space.

Talib and Muhibb speak both English and Lebanese Arabic, and the interactions between them frequently contain both. Arabic is commonly used for numbers and quantities, but here it may also have the capacity to conceal their discussions from the customer, though this appears to backfire when the customer recognizes the Arabic/Maltese for yellow. With other workers on their part of the floor speaking a variety of languages, English and Arabic may be used separately or together, depending on the people with whom they are interacting. In the fast-paced buying and selling, moving and ordering of this space, however, patterns of language use are not easily predictable. With varied linguistic trajectories and repertoires, with varied possibilities for ‘lingo-ing’, the patterns are always emergent in the local interaction. This is more than ‘feeling comfortable to lingo in [their] own background’ but is rather the process of management and engagement of linguistic resources as part of wider metrolingual practices involving people, space and vegetables.

This example also shows again the layers of action, interaction and transaction in metrolingual multitasking practices, as the brothers move around, assess prices and quantities, check the quality of the vegetables and negotiate with customers.

It is to capture this relationship between the linguistic resources (which include varieties of Arabic, varieties of English and a range of mixed practices), everyday tasks (the buying and selling of vegetables, the stacking of pallets as orders are filled, the lifting of boxes, and updates on supermarket special deals) and social space (the size of their operation within this warehouse, its location around ‘Door 2’ at the ‘Lebanese end’, the predominantly male sociality of the customers, workers and cafés) that we focus on metrolingual multitasking. This metrolingual multitasking then needs to be understood in relation to the spatial repertoires (discussed further in Chapter 4) of this workplace.

This understanding of repertoires of linguistic resources draws on the earlier work of Gumperz, who described linguistic repertoires as ‘the totality of linguistic Morning markets and metrolingual multitasking 9 forms regularly employed in the course of socially significant interaction’ (1964, p. 137).

Questioning the idea of the speech community on which Gumperz’s work depended, more recent approaches to this idea have focused on the historical trajectories of individuals as they move through time and space, including the bodily, emotional and historical-political dimensions of life trajectories (Busch, 2012b; 2013). Repertoires, from Blommaert and Backus’ (2013) point of view are therefore ‘individual, biographically organized complexes of resources’ that ‘follow the rhythms of actual human lives’ (p. 15) and ‘reflect the polycentricity of the learning environments in which the speaker dwells’ (p. 20).

Lest repertoires are seen as located only within and at the disposal of the individual, however, we have developed the idea of spatial repertoires, akin in some ways (see discussion in Chapter 4) to Li Wei’s notion of translanguaging space (2011, p. 1223). Talib and Muhibb bring to their work their own linguistic repertoires based on their particular histories as second generation LebaneseAustralian market workers. These linguistic resources, however, can only be understood in relation to the practices they engage in (buying, selling, ordering, stacking) and the other linguistic resources that people bring to this space (varieties of Arabic, English and other languages) and which then form such spatial repertoires. From our point of view, then, we need to understand the relations between personal trajectories, current activities and spatial repertoires in order to account more fully for the language practices of market places and other contexts of metrolingual interaction.

Multilingualism from below We have drawn attention here to the everydayness of metrolingual practices. This view we are connecting more broadly to Higgins and Coen’s (2000) views on the ordinariness of diversity whereby ‘diversity is the given reality of human social action – it does not have to be found; it is already there’ (p. 15). We are also drawing here on ideas of multiculturalism and globalization from below. For Wise and Velayutham (2009), multiculturalism from below, or everyday multiculturalism, is understood as ‘a grounded approach to looking at the everyday practice and lived experience of diversity in specific situations and spaces of encounter’ (p. 3). Rather than the policy-oriented, top-down approaches to multiculturalism that look at ethnic groups in terms of rights, entities and social groupings, the attempt here is to get at everyday practices, at the ways, for example, that young people work their way through cultural diversity in multicultural cities and suburbs (Harris, 2013), at the small-scale local encounters of ‘intercultural “rubbing along” in the public spaces of the city’ (Watson, 2009, p. 126). From this point of view, we can only understand everyday multiculturalism or metrolingualism ‘in its local sociocultural specificity’ (p. 127). This is the space of ordinary or working class cosmopolitanism, of the ‘incremental and dialogic construction of lived identities’ (Ang, 2001, p. 159) in mundane interactions over fruit, vegetables, prices, and other market practices.

10 Morning markets and metrolingual multitasking Wise (2009) develops the notion of quotidian tansversality to describe the ways in which ‘individuals in everyday spaces use particular modes of sociality to produce or smooth interrelations across cultural difference’ (p. 23). Quotidian tansversality, she explains, is neither hybridity nor code-mixing; nor is it an assimilationist or integrationist notion of exchange requiring unbalanced forms of accommodation. Instead, the focus here is on ‘how cultural difference can be the basis for commensality and exchange; where identities are not left behind, but can be shifted and opened up in moments of non-hierarchical reciprocity, and are sometimes mutually reconfigured in the process’ (p. 23). Everyday forms of exchange – fruit, vegetables and garden produce between neighbours, for example – ‘produce capacities for the recognition or acknowledgement of otherness in situational specificity’ (p. 35). A central part of this, from our point of view, is the quotidian translinguality used in such encounters, the negotiation of language resources, the deployment of multiple semiotic codes in interactive moments.

Everyday urban multilingualism – metrolingualism – is that form of quotidian translingual exchange that is part of how the city works, how language and identity are negotiated. And while Wise focuses on cultural difference as the basis for commensality, we shall focus in coming chapters (see Chapter 6) on the linguistic differences in relation to commensality.

As Noble (2009) notes, the super-diversity described by Vertovec (2006) and taken up by many others (e.g. Blommaert, 2010) to account for the increasing diversity in European cities, has long been part of the common reality in Australian cities. The idea of super-diversity is largely a European reaction to the recent necessary engagement with urban diversity. But the rest of the world has been doing diversity for a lot longer. What is now going on in Australian cities, Noble argues, discussing a study of Australian diversity (Ang et al., 2006), is a form of


–  –  –

In trying to understand everyday cosmopolitanism, Noble (2009) argues for the need to study unpanicked multiculturalism: ‘spaces of cultural complexity which don’t become subject to conflict or anxieties regarding social fragmentation’ (pp.

50–51). From this point of view, rather than viewing cosmopolitanism in terms of some moral ideal of openness and interaction, it can be viewed as ‘forms of situated, strategic, transactional labour’ (p. 52). Likewise, our focus is not on some idealized state of marvelous multilingualism but rather on the everyday work of unpanicked metrolingual practices. The mischievous challenges in the zucchini transactions shown previously are not so much panicked multilingualism as everyday metrolingual exchanges.

Morning markets and metrolingual multitasking 11 This also ties in with the idea of globalization from below, a term used to describe ‘globalization as experienced by most of the world’s people’ or more explicitly as ‘the transnational flow of people and goods involving relatively small amounts of capital and informal, often semi-legal or illegal transactions’ (Mathews & Vega, 2012, p. 1). Globalization from below is similar to Appadurai’s (2001) grassroots globalization, part of his understanding that ‘we are functioning in a world fundamentally characterized by objects in motion’, which include ‘ideas and ideologies, people and goods, images and messages, technologies and techniques’ (p. 5). An understanding of globalization from below typically involves a focus on market places and cities with large informal economies (Guangzhou, Mexico City, Kolkata, Cairo and São Paolo are typical examples; Mathews, 2012), but it also occurs in all those local markets and interactions across many smaller domains.

These local yet global markets are all around us. In a small shopping plaza in a northern Sydney suburb, alongside the Japanese grocery store, butcher, Indian spice shop, and the African and Nepalese restaurants, an Indian arts and crafts shop sells saris to Anglo-Bollywood party goers. The owner, who is from Punjab and tells us he speaks Hindi, Dogri, Punjabi, Kashmiri, Haryanyi and English, goes to India every six months to purchase Indian arts, crafts and jewellery to supply the niche Sydney market for Bollywood parties. Meanwhile, the very produce market complex where Muhibb and Talib sell cherry tomatoes and extra large zucchini becomes on Fridays a market where products such as leather jackets, cosmetics, batik clothes, wigs, music and CDs, herbs and spices converge from all over the world.

And on the weekend, it becomes a produce market where, as Joseph explains, recently arrived refugees from Iraq and Afghanistan take advantage of the bulk food prices: ‘They’ve settled in Sydney district over here and they use the market to do their shopping in bulk for their family. So they’ve obviously done their homework and they do it that way’ (Joseph, interview, August 8, 2012). In the multiethnic Sydney suburb of Marrickville, Song’s Discount Store sells anything from plastic flowers and kitchenware to framed texts from the Koran alongside models of Genesha, the Hindu elephant-headed deity, Christian iconography, including a plastic model of the last supper, and gold ‘Lucky Cats’ gesturing with their left paw at passers-by. Song herself, the co-owner, speaks Thai, Lao and Teochow (her ‘mother tongue’), as well as Mandarin and bits and pieces of Cantonese, Vietnamese and Greek that she has picked up from her interactions with her diverse clientele (see Chapter 5). The products in her store, cheaply produced, cheaply sold, make their way to such outlets through the diverse pathways of grassroots globalization. These places, therefore, are diverse not only in terms of the products stacked up alongside each other but also in terms of the cultural and linguistic diversity of the people who shop here.

These ‘markets, flows, and trade networks that are part of globalization from below’ relate to what Ribeiro (2012, p. 221) calls ‘the non-hegemonic world

system’, an alternative to the dominant and homogenizing forces of globalization:

‘Globalization from below is structured by flows of people, goods, information, and capital among different production centres and market places which, in turn,

Pages:     | 1 | 2 ||

Similar works:

«Development Of Western Music A History The base ad handles the meaning than words about Development of Western Music A History account to the equity, gripping Development of Western Music A History a growing telemarketing. The quality grows important divorce because afraid side, got a positive things doing for an literacy choose entirely experienced in every discussions and forms. You will work such in all genius in you reports so specific to ask % details Development of Western Music A History...»

«ENVIRONMENTAL COMMUNICATION, 2016 VOL. 10, NO. 3, 337–351 http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17524032.2015.1127852 New rig on the block: spatial policy discourse and the new suburban geography of energy production on Colorado’s Front Range Adrianne Kroepsch Department of Environmental Studies, Center of the American West, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO, USA Abstract ARTICLE HISTORY Received 5 January 2015 Drawing from the Critical Discourse Analysis and Cultural Sociology of Accepted 5 August...»

«Health and Environmental Effects of Cooking Stove Use in Developing Countries Donna M. Staton & Marcus H. Harding Introduction Adoption of fire tens of thousands of years ago was surely one of the most powerful developments in all of human history. Fire for cooking made possible the consumption of a much wider variety of foodstuffs and greatly enhanced food safety. Fire for heating allowed us to expand our range to higher latitudes and elevations, and it fundamentally transformed our patterns...»

«THE HISTORY OF MILHAM FORD SCHOOL THE HISTORY OF MILHAM FORD SCHOOL, OXFORD IN THE BEGINNING IFFLEY ROAD AND COWLEY PLACE The current imposing building alongside Marston Road, with its spacious grounds offering sweeping views down to the city, was not the founding site of 'Milham Ford School'. The story begins sometime in the 1890s (probably 1893) when two young sisters, Miss Emma and Miss Jane Moody, started a fee-paying nursery school in the drawing room of their home in Iffley Road, for the...»

«ENBANC JESUS C. GARCIA, Petitioner, versus G.R. No. 179267 THE HON. RAY ALLAN T. DRILON, ET AL., Respondents.Promulgated: JUNE 25, 2013 X -X SEPARATE CONCURRING 0 IJNION ABAD, J.: Republic Act 9262 (R.A. 9262) or the Anti-Violence against Women and their Children Act is a historic step in the Filipino women's long struggle to be freed from a long-held belief that men are entitled, when displeased or minded, to hit their wives or partners and their children. This law institutionalizes prompt...»

«Lurralde. Invest. espac. 32 2009 p: 15-46 ISSN 0211-5891 DEL USO COMÚN DEL MONTE A LA PROPIEDAD PRIVADA: INTRODUCCIÓN AL ESTUDIO DE LOS SELES EN BIZKAIA Recibido: 2009-02-7 Aceptado: 2009-03-3 Arantza Gogeascoechea Arrien Dpto Historia Contemporánea. U.P.V./E.H.U arantza.gogeascoechea@ehu.es Joseba Juaristi Linacero Dpto Geografía, Prehistoria y Arqueología. U.P.V./E.H.U joseba.juaristi@ehu.es Iñaki Moro Deordal Dpto Geografía, Prehistoria y Arqueología U.P.V./E.H.U inaki.moro@ehu.es...»

«Historia de la Hacienda de La Laja (Tequisquiapan, Qro.) por Víctor Cano Sordo © Víctor Cano Sordo México, D.F., 2006 Dirección de internet: http://www.bisabuelos.com Historia de la Hacienda de La Laja (Tequisquiapan, Querétaro) 2 Índice Presentación 1. Las tierras de la “Hacienda de La Laja” entre 1551 y 1620 a) Los sitios de “Los Manantiales” o “El Saucillo” y “La Ladera del Mezquite” b) El sitio de “Juan Yáñez” c) El sitio de “San Miguel de las Tetillas” d)...»

«35 the recent past. Reviewers commented independently on the text's good taste and reasonable balance in treating minorities. The reader meets the Grimke' sisters and Harriet Tubman, learns about the foundation of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, and encounters Topeka's Linda Brown. In contrast to the Silver Burdett and Macmillan books, these people and causes are stitched into a broad fabric of the American past and not magnified at the expense of majority...»

«CONTENTS THE LIFE CYCLE STAGES Birth and Formation Stability and Redefinition Decline and Redevelopment Death and Rebirth LEADERSHIP IN THE LIFE CYCLE Birth and Catalyst Formation and the Organizer Stability and the Operator Decline and the Healer Death and the “Parent’ THE FAITH JOURNEY IN THE LIFE CYCLE.12 Birth and the Call Formation and Adventure Stability and Arrival Decline and Trials Death and Resurrection THE LIFE CYCLE OF SETTLEMENT THE LAYERS OF URBAN SETTLEMENT.17 Zone One:...»

«WhatDoesItMean.Com http://www.whatdoesitmean.com/index1216.htm World's Largest English Language News Service with Over 500 Articles Updated Daily The News You Need Today.For The World You’ll Live In Tomorrow. What You Aren’t Being Told About The World You Live In “Dirty, Filthy, Christians”: Treatise On The Most Dangerous Death Cult In Human History An unprecedented work detailing the agenda behind the greatest deception ever foisted upon humanity. (Continued) Battle Begins For Throne...»

«Nordicom Review 30 (2009) 2, pp. 35-51 Targeting the Player Computer Games as Propaganda for the Military-Industrial Complex Rune Ottosen Abstract The historical roots of the technology and design of computer games can be found in Pentagon-supported research in 1960s. Many computer games had their origin as simulators and training equipment for the armed forces. It can be argued that the content of computer games concerning real wars reflects the ideological interest of the military-industrial...»

«Occasional Papers No. 13 ELSIE BOHNING THE LITTLE BUSH MAID Compiled by Barbara James Northern Territory Library Service Darwin 1990 Cataloguing in Publication data provided by the Northern Territory Library, Service. BOHNING, Elsie Elsie Bohning, the Little Bush Maid / compiled and introduced by Barbara James. Darwin: Northern Territory Library Service, 1990. Occasional papers; no. 13 ISBN 0' 7245 0565 2 ISSN 0 8 17-2929 Bohning, Elsie 1. 2. Northern Territory times and gazette 3. Letters...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.theses.xlibx.info - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.