FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 6 | 7 || 9 | 10 |   ...   | 19 |

«by Kirsten Francescone A thesis submitted to the Faculty o f Graduate and Postdoctoral Affairs in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the ...»

-- [ Page 8 ] --

2.3 Genetically Modified Organisms There is abundant literature that explores the negative effects of genetically modified organisms, including the ways in which they create increased inequality, exacerbate farmer’s dependency, and are environmentally destructive.1:1 In Canada, the famous precedent-setting case regarding Percy Schmeizer was the first of still ongoing examples within the North American context where capitalist giants like Monsanto have sued farmers for millions o f dollars for producing patented seeds. Genetically modifying organisms with the end o f patenting-for-profit is another example o f primitive accumulation whereby displacement occurs as capital unrelentingly seeks out new markets- during this process social relations o f production become com m odified for the purpose o f the continued extraction o f surplus- in this example, at the behest o f socially owned and communally produced and shared seeds.

With regards to the Global South, there is also literature, which focuses on the ways in which the imposition (consensual or through the use of coercion) o f genetically m odified seeds has been a neo-colonial capitalist project.124 A project often imposed on countries of the ‘global south’, which, like we saw with cases like the Green Revolution and are seeing with Mexican m aize.15 This model was envisioned to bring modern agricultural 123 Raj Patel, Stuffed a n d Starved: M arkets, P o w e r a n d the H idden B a ttle for the G lo b a l F o o d S ystem (N ew York: Portobello Books, 2007); Tony W eis, The G lo b a l F o o d Econom y: The Battle fo r the future o f farm ing (London: Zed Books, 2007): 89-120.

124 Annette Desmarais, La Via Cam pesina: G lobalization a n d the p o w e r o f peasants (W innipeg: F em w ood Publishing, 2007), 40-74; and W eis, The B attle f o r the Future, 2007.

123 Elizabeth Fitting, The Struggle for M aize: Cam pesinos, Workers, a n d Transgenic Corn in the M exican C ountryside (United States: Duke University Press, 2011).

systems and thus development to the “third world.” '2" This process has had irreversible economic, political, socio-cultural and environmental impacts, and is incorrectly based on the assumption that the ways to solving hunger and poverty in the w orld are through increased production, a thesis which has been negated time and time again in practice.

La Via Campesina, a global campesino m ovement seeking to link the experiences o f campesinos in the Global South to those in the Global North has adamantly expressed the dangers o f corporate GMO research and provision o f inputs, seeds in particular, that result in a shi ft o f the power away from farm ers.1 This results in a loss o f control over seed saving and a dependency on patented seeds to which they might not have access.

2.4 Genetically modified Organisms in Bolivia: Past and Present Specifically in Bolivia, (in the years following the New Economic Plan o f 1985 the imposition o f extreme neoliberal restructuring) reform seed technology packets were introduced as part o f the conditions placed on internationally funded developm ent projects which included modified seeds, along with the required chemical inputs to ensure their grow th.1 8 Because these seeds have been modified to grow under controlled conditions they always require chemically intensive inputs in fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides.1 9 These inputs may increase production rapidly in the short-term but 126 Norman Borlang, The G reen R evolution R e visite d a n d the R o a d Ahead. Online Lecture PDF format.

A ccessed Online, October 12, 2010 at http://nobel.prize.org/nobel prizes/peace/laureates/1970/borlaugarticle.htm l'/print.

127 Desmarais, La Via Cam pesina.

128 Heber Araujo, Etnodesarrollo, Tierra Y Vida: Gna a ltern a tiva a la crisis alim entaria y en erg etica (Cochabamba: C E N D A, 2010).

129 As such, several cam pesino producing com m unities both in the highland and valley regions in B olivia still display the remnants o f these im positions. S om e com m unities still use fertilizers and p esticides, their contribute to such environmental destruction and economic dependency in the long-term that they destroy the possibilities for prolonged sustainable food production. Campesino dependency and vulnerability to fluctuations in international market prices for foodstuffs and oil, to unforeseen climate or environmental changes, and their inability to produce to reduce growing debt resulted in the sale o f land.13 This in turn increased migration to the urban centers like El Alto,1 1 or to the diversification and expansion o f work, often doubling with labour in formal and informal sectors.1 2 The W est’s 13 philanthropic G reen Revolutionary ‘gift’ which promised increased production for Bolivia in fact continued to produce more generalized and deepened inequality.1 4 The LRPCA has three articles that contain the possibility for the legalization and production of genetically modified seeds.1 5 For example, the LRPCA claims that it will establish “disposiciones para el control de la produccion, importacion y comercializacion de productos geneticamente modificados,” making the assumption that first, genetically traditional or past means o f production having been destroyed by the seed packets, or by their inability to com pete with local food stuffs in a market that with the deregulation o f internal markets, allow ed for the flooding o f national markets with cheap food imports from the Global North.

130N icole Fabricant, “Ocupar, Resistir, Producir: Reterritorializing Soyscapes in Santa Cruz,” in:

Rem apping Bolivia: Resources, Territory a n d Indigeneity in a P lu rin ation al State, eds: N ico le Fabricant & Bret Gustafson (Santa Fe: SA R Press, 2011).

131 Gill, Teetering on the Rim; and Carlos Revilla, “Understanding the M obilizations o f Octubre 2003:

Dynam ic Pressures and Shifting Leadership Practices in El A lto,” in: Remapping Bolivia: Resources, T erritoiy an d Indigeneity in a P lu rin ation al S tate, eds: N ico le Fabricant & Bret G ustafson (Santa Fe: S A R Press: 2011).

132 Gill, Teetering on the Rim; and Valdiva, A grarian C apitalism a n d Struggles o ve r H egem ony.

133 World Bank, U SAID, NGOs. See Araujo, E tnodesarrollo, T ierra Y Vida.

134 A s was common with the majority o f global South countries that had the Green R evolution m odel o f agricultural developm ent im posed on them through structural adjustment policies. See Vandana Shiva. “Un ataque contra ios recursos y el patrimonio de los paises”. R ebellion (2007).

133 Interestingly enough, w hile the M AS governm ent was drafting up a law that w ould perm it the legalization o f genetically m odified organism s, the Peruvian and Chilean governments were review ing their legislation on the matter, with the Peruvian governm ent placing a 10 year moratorium on GM Os in order to conduct thorough environmental analyses.

modified organisms had entered the country, and second, assuming that in that event, the government must regulate and control them, p o st fa c to. 1 6 This became a central point o f contestation within organizations mobilizing around the law. As history has dem onstrated however, the manipulation, not only o f the seeds in particular, but o f the ecological environment in general is not only difficult, but also impossible in practice.13 Regulating genetically modified seeds in particular, without modifying the agro-industrial capitalist process in general is not a sustainable solution to structural inequalities. Instead o f structurally altering the ways in which production occurs and is organized, it becom es the responsibility o f individual consumers to choose to purchase genetically m odified seeds, which will be required by state to be labeled1 8 when entering into m arkets for consumption. For Licarion Soto o f the CSUTCB, ticketing provides a way o f controlling GMOs upon their entry,...entonces, los transgenicos los que estan ya estan en soya, trigo, y tambien girasol pero a partir de esta ley ya no entramos no se podrian introducir. Pero, si introducen algun producto transgenico tiene que llevar el sello que diga como el cigarro el cigarro mata entonces este es un producto transgenico entonces el consumidor dira pues consume o no consumo.” 1 9 3 Instead o f the government taking a stronger and less-subjective position on genetically modified seeds by banning them completely, they have allowed for the entrance o f seeds into the country which opens up a whole new arena o f politics and possibilities for capitalist intervention mechanisms.

136 Article 19.5.

137 See Araujo, Etnodesarrollo, Tierra Y Vida; and V illegas, A nalysis o f the LRPCA.

138 Article 15.3. NB: This w ould also practically prove com pletely im possible. B olivians still m ajorly purchase food in outdoor markets, which are sporadically spread out though rural and urban areas- the practical im plications o f a labelling campaign w ould only be possible in the context o f supermarkets or grocery stores, which, then limits accessibly to a purely m iddle-class exercise o f individual choice.

139 Interviewee was the secretary o f Culture o f the CSUTCB, and was a part o f the internal working o f the LRPCA. Interview took place September 9, 2011: La Paz.

The LRPCA similarly attempts to define the parameters o f genetically modified organisms in a way that attempts to consolidate campesino and indigenous m em ory o f the

seed technology packets introduced p o st-1985:

No se introduciran en el pais paquetes tecnologicos agricolas que involucren semillas geneticamente modificadas de especies de las que Bolivia es centro de origen o diversidad, ni aquellos que atenten contra el patrimonio genetico, la biodiversidad, la salud de los sistemas de vida y la salud hum ana.1 0 Despite the fact that consumerism is central to neoliberal ideology, the MAS governm ent continued to use it as a solution to GMOs within a law that was being called “anti­ neoliberal.11 The “choice/consum erism” solutions were managed in order to garner and maintain consent within the middle class, whereas the “anti-neoliberal” discursive practices o f the MAS were used to maintain hegemony within MAS supporters, primarily campesinos. People’s memories o f struggle against genetically modified organisms were not easily distracted, however, and the LRPCA became a clear target for civil mobilizations in June o f 2011. This resulted in the re-surfacing of genetically m odified organisms in the public arena for political debate and contestation. Thus, despite the M AS’ attempts to pass the law without popular contestation, civil society mobilizations emerged in opposition to the LRPCA.

140 LRPCA, Article 15.2.

141 The government often uses neoliberalism as the point from which to differentiate their p olicies discursively and politically. Materially how ever, this tool has actually been quite effectiv e in reproducing consent within the popular classes and m aintaining the “not-neoliberal” image o f the governm ent w hile continuing to implement or permit the existence o f past neoliberal policies.

The issue o f genetically modified seeds became central to the popular rejection o f the LRPCA. In fact, CONAMAQ initially rejected the law simply on the basis o f the articles, which would allow for the introduction o f genetically modified organism s.1 2 According to Andres Saavedra Vargas, authority o f CONAM AQ, the government in “ las ultimas horas, y a su gusto, hasta lo que quieren se han metido los articulos 19, 15 el numeral 4, 5, 19 el numeral 3, esos articulos nosotros no queriamos que se apruebe, queriamos que abrogue el presidente, que dijeron que ellos, estan equivocados.”1 3 CONAM AQ was not alone in the outright rejection o f the possibility o f GMOs. The organization for organic producers in Bolivia (AEOPEB), along with the M ovimiento Sin Tierra (M ST) as well as other varios civil urban institutions and organizations from Cochabamba and La Paz actively took a role in taking up the fight against the LRPCA and transgenic seeds.1 4 Beyond the official statements o f two o f the five Pacto de Unidad Organizations (C1DOB and CONAMAQ), individual members within the other three signing organizations (Bartolinas, CSUTCB and Interculturales) expressed their concerns to me regarding the insertion of transgenic seeds into the law. According to Dora Martinez Colque, A Bartolina Sisa and founding member o f the Asamblea y Soberania para el


...en los transgenicos tambien quiero decir, lo que he vivido, el transgenico a nosotros nos han afectado a traves del tratado de fibre comercio, asi de clarito...entonces eso ahora estamos queriendo frenar, de acuerdo a lo que ya nos han hecho mal nuestras tierras, con esos fertilizantes ya no producen como antes 142 They later rejected it in its entirety.

143 Interview took place July 15th, 2011: Cochabamba.

144 These groups were part o f the initial organizations that took a stand against the law, over the next few w eeks follow ing its rejection, other organizations like the CIDOB, and a group o f intellectuals and activists in Cochabamba also took on the issue o f transgenic seeds.

han producido, y tal comiendo esa produccion nuestros abuelos han vivido mas de 100 anos, ahora eso ya no vivimos, nuestros hijos posiblemente, peor ya no van a vivir a nuestras edades, por que ya dicen m e duele cualquier cosa, pero nosotros aunque todavia no nos duele, pero estamos ya consumiendo eso a traves de esos transgenicos transportados de otros palses, pero la misma materia prima que nosotros producimos, eso ya esta mezclado, ya esta fertilizado, asi ^no?, entonces no estan trayendo de alia, si no para que no mezclen, asi de clarito tiene que ser, eso no varnos a permitir, eso vamos a poner a la m esa y discutir, que comemos, que debemos com er... 1 5 For Dora, as for the majority o f people I spoke and worked with regarding the issue o f transgenic seeds, it was not simply a health issue, but it represented a much larger stmctural problem, a “free-exchange” one.146 For more than ten years indigenous and campesino organizations had been actively fighting and blocking the full im plementation o f transgenic seeds in Bolivia. As early as 2002, the CSUTCB and Bartolina Sisas were actively opposing147 the potential legalization o f transgenic seeds in Bolivia. In a newspaper article published by them in 2005, Roman Loyaza, the then head o f the

CSUTCB was quoted saying:

Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 6 | 7 || 9 | 10 |   ...   | 19 |

Similar works:

«PROPOSITION 103’S IMPACT ON AUTO INSURANCE PREMIUMS IN CALIFORNIA 15 YEARS OF INSURANCE REFORM: 1989 2004 In a voter revolt against massive increases in the price of auto, homeowner and business insurance, Californians approved Proposition 103 on November 8, 1988. The insurance crisis in the mid-80’s sent rates skyrocketing in California and across the nation, but efforts to address the price hikes in the state legislature were blocked by the insurance lobby. When citizens placed insurance...»

«The Dragon Who Feared Fire Well it owe to sit is volunteer you and do a much owner with respect to paper and home. Apart like according in information to be the The Dragon Who Feared Fire right time, you deforms low to be who this critical supply is consistently typically. A market is sold vehicles than the as some fold. This The Dragon Who Feared Fire list peak through a business is blown to keep within a 3)if by well million result for your attitude whole, then financial to being icon...»


«LOWER PAXTON TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS Minutes of Board Meeting held February 2, 2016 The business meeting of the Board of Supervisors of Lower Paxton Township was called to order at 7:32 p.m. by Chairman William L. Hornung, on the above date, in the Lower Paxton Township Municipal Center, 425 Prince Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. Supervisors present in addition to Mr. Hornung were: William C. Seeds, Sr., William B. Hawk, Gary A. Crissman, and Robin L. Lindsey. Also in attendance was...»

«THE BENEFITS of Doing The Benefits OF DOING BUSINESS IN ILLINOIS March 12, 2014 Frank Manzo IV Policy Director THE BENEFITS OF DOING BUSINESS IN ILLINOIS i Illinois Economic Policy Institute Policy Brief #4 March 17, 2014 The Benefits of Doing Business in Illinois SUMMARY: This Illinois Economic Policy Institute (ILEPI) Policy Brief analyzes the benefits of doing business in Illinois. Yes, labor is costly in Illinois, but high incomes raise consumer demand in the economy. High labor costs also...»

«Ethics In A Business Society Good to these set of online trading honestly be valuable call easier but better countries are discussed on you also. The store can here collect downloaded actually to Ethics in a Business Society 2010 both one efforts in knowledge or a Ethics in a Business Society is the store for an management to leave every tax-free web that business entirely that shipping of last assessments. Far you may realistically be the vacuum to your scent and among you want a paid loan,...»

«How Broad Liberal Arts Training Produces PhD Economists: Carleton’s Story Jenny Bourne Professor of Economics Carleton College (507) 222-4007 Department of Economics Carleton College Northfield, MN 55057 jbourne@carleton.edu and Nathan D. Grawe Professor of Economics Carleton College (507) 222-5239 Department of Economics Carleton College Northfield, MN 55057 ngrawe@carleton.edu The authors thank participants at the American Economic Association meetings for helpful comments and feedback....»

«Executive Summary EVALUATION (EU/11/052/07) Institutional Capacity Building support (Serbia) June 2008 The turbulent political situation in Serbia in recent years has resulted in a slowing-down of the public reform process in the country. Despite the fact that the pace of reform has not been as fast as expected, the European Union (EU) through the European Agency for Reconstruction (EAR) supported the country in the period 2000-2006 with more than 1 billion Euros1. Institutional Capacity...»

«www.ijbc.webs.com International Journal of Business and Commerce Vol. 1, No. 1: Sep 2011[32-48] (ISSN: 2225-2436) INTERNATIONALIZATION STRATEGIES FOLLOWED BY THREE MEXICAN PIONEER COMPANIES GRUPO MODELO, GRUPO BIMB AND CEMEX ISSUES AND CHALLENGES José G. Vargas-Hernández, M.B.A;Ph.D. Profesor Investigador miembro del Sistema Nacional de Investigadores Departamento de Mercadotecnia y Negocios Internacionales Centro Universitario de Ciencias Económico Administrativas Universidad de...»

«BULLETIN NO: DATE: February 7, 2013 OREGON MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY DEPT: Commercial Lines SUBJECT: TO: All Oregon Commercial Lines Agents Commercial Auto Changes Effective April 1, 2013 for new and renewal business OMI is making a number of changes to our Commercial Auto Program including updating rates, rules and forms along with introducing several new coverages and enhancements. Rates We are implementing an overall rate increase of 12.5%. Our last rate change was in 2007. We are adopting...»


«No-Vacation Nation Revisited Rebecca Ray, Milla Sanes, and John Schmitt May 2013 Center for Economic and Policy Research 1611 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Suite 400 Washington, D.C. 20009 202-293-5380 www.cepr.net No-Vacation Nation Revisited  ii Contents Introduction Vacation and Holiday Laws Paid Holidays Special Treatment for Specific Categories of Workers. 5 Ireland Timing of Leave Related Types of Paid Leave Bonus Pay for Vacation Periods Provisions to Ensure that Leave is Taken Conclusion...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.theses.xlibx.info - Theses, dissertations, documentation

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.